Part of how I love to experience wine is with food. Recently I have been fortunate enough to have several dinners with wine pairings and always wondered if it was a bit of a myth. Do certain wines pair with food better than
others?
The history of wine and food pairings is very cultural. Wine, for a very long time, has been a staple at the
dinner table across many cultures. Therefore the habit of pairing international
wines with their corresponding cuisine became the basis for many wine and food
pairings today. However, eventually the act of pairing became an art form – one
practiced by some of the most high-end restaurants today.
But I do still wonder – do
some wines actually enhance the experience of eating certain foods.
According to many food and wine experts it does – at least at a
basic level. The most basic element of food and wine pairing is the balance
between the “weight” of the food and the “body” of the wine. Robust wines, such
as reds (e.g., Cabernet Sauvignon) would overpower a light, delicate dish, such
as a quiche or a fish. Whereas, light-bodied wines, such as Pinot
Grigio, would be overwhelmed by a boeuf bourgignon. Basically –
you want to be able to enjoy the taste of both your wine and your food without
either one overpowering the other.
It isn’t just food and wine experts – scientists agree too. Findings published in Current Biology
suggests that “mouthfeel", the way food feels in our mouths, is responsible for
the phenomenon. For example, Astringent wines often feel rough and dry in the
mouth, whereas fats are slippery. Eating them together helps balance the two
out. In the study’s summary, authors refer to this “balancing” mechanism as
“palate cleansing.” As a result, they found that participants in the study
provided lower ratings of fattiness and stringency for the food and wine that
they were tasting relative to rinsing with water.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI find this topic really interesting, and I'm always conflicted in precisely how to think about a subject like this.
ReplyDeleteHow should I actually think about pairing wine and food -- should it be an experiment, or an experience? Should I be thinking about the science at all, or is life too short?
I find studies or research like this to be of the kind that applies to an aggregate (e.g. to winemakers, it's important to understand taste preferences, combinations, etc.), but perhaps less relevant on the individual level (i.e. what does the "average taste" really do for me?).
I know I'm honing in on just a specific element of what you laid out above, but I think it's worth considering when to apply the objective, and when to abide by the subjective. I wonder what someone at the intersection -- a sommelier -- with deep, objective understanding of taste profiles and certainly his/her own personal preferences would say.